rfc9796v1.txt | rfc9796.txt | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
skipping to change at line 69 ¶ | skipping to change at line 69 ¶ | |||
2. Terminology | 2. Terminology | |||
3. Overview | 3. Overview | |||
4. A Call-Info Framework for Carrying Rich Call Data | 4. A Call-Info Framework for Carrying Rich Call Data | |||
5. "jcard" Call-Info 'purpose' Token | 5. "jcard" Call-Info 'purpose' Token | |||
6. 'call-reason' Call-Info Parameter | 6. 'call-reason' Call-Info Parameter | |||
7. 'verified' Call-Info Parameter | 7. 'verified' Call-Info Parameter | |||
8. 'integrity' Call-Info Parameter | 8. 'integrity' Call-Info Parameter | |||
9. Usage and an Example of Call-Info for RCD | 9. Usage and an Example of Call-Info for RCD | |||
10. Usage of jCard and Property-Specific Usage | 10. Usage of jCard and Property-Specific Usage | |||
10.1. Usage of URIs in jCard | 10.1. Usage of URIs in jCard | |||
10.2. Usage of Multimedia Data in jCard or with Icon | 10.2. Usage of Multimedia Data in jCard or with the “icon” | |||
Call-Info ‘purpose’ Token | ||||
10.3. Cardinality | 10.3. Cardinality | |||
10.4. Identification Properties | 10.4. Identification Properties | |||
10.4.1. "fn" Property | 10.4.1. "fn" Property | |||
10.4.2. "n" Property | 10.4.2. "n" Property | |||
10.4.3. "nickname" Property | 10.4.3. "nickname" Property | |||
10.4.4. "photo" Property | 10.4.4. "photo" Property | |||
10.5. Delivery Addressing Properties | 10.5. Delivery Addressing Properties | |||
10.5.1. "adr" Property | 10.5.1. "adr" Property | |||
10.6. Communications Properties | 10.6. Communications Properties | |||
10.6.1. "tel" Property | 10.6.1. "tel" Property | |||
skipping to change at line 99 ¶ | skipping to change at line 100 ¶ | |||
10.8.4. "org" Property | 10.8.4. "org" Property | |||
10.9. Explanatory Properties | 10.9. Explanatory Properties | |||
10.9.1. "categories" Property | 10.9.1. "categories" Property | |||
10.9.2. "note" Property | 10.9.2. "note" Property | |||
10.9.3. "sound" Property | 10.9.3. "sound" Property | |||
10.9.4. "uid" Property | 10.9.4. "uid" Property | |||
10.9.5. "url" Property | 10.9.5. "url" Property | |||
10.9.6. "version" Property | 10.9.6. "version" Property | |||
11. Extension of jCard | 11. Extension of jCard | |||
12. IANA Considerations | 12. IANA Considerations | |||
12.1. 'jcard' Purpose Parameter Value | 12.1. "jcard" Purpose Parameter Value | |||
12.2. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'call-reason' Parameter | 12.2. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'call-reason' Parameter | |||
12.3. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'verified' Parameter | 12.3. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'verified' Parameter | |||
12.4. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'integrity' Parameter | 12.4. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'integrity' Parameter | |||
13. Security Considerations | 13. Security Considerations | |||
14. References | 14. References | |||
14.1. Normative References | 14.1. Normative References | |||
14.2. Informative References | 14.2. Informative References | |||
Acknowledgements | Acknowledgements | |||
Authors' Addresses | Authors' Addresses | |||
skipping to change at line 127 ¶ | skipping to change at line 128 ¶ | |||
can carry a 'display-name' in the From header field value from the | can carry a 'display-name' in the From header field value from the | |||
originating to terminating side, though it is a field that is not | originating to terminating side, though it is a field that is not | |||
commonly trusted and is often replaced or ignored. The same can be | commonly trusted and is often replaced or ignored. The same can be | |||
considered true of information in the Call-Info header field in SIP. | considered true of information in the Call-Info header field in SIP. | |||
This document defines usage of the SIP Call-Info header field | This document defines usage of the SIP Call-Info header field | |||
[RFC3261] that allows called parties to receive a more comprehensive | [RFC3261] that allows called parties to receive a more comprehensive | |||
and extensible set of Rich Call Data (RCD) for incoming calls. It | and extensible set of Rich Call Data (RCD) for incoming calls. It | |||
defines specific usage of the Call-Info header field, a new parameter | defines specific usage of the Call-Info header field, a new parameter | |||
('call-reason'), and a new token ("jcard") for the 'purpose' | ('call-reason'), and a new token ("jcard") for the 'purpose' | |||
parameter of the Call-Info header field. For this document and | parameter of the Call-Info header field. Depending on the policies | |||
depending on the policies of the communications system, a calling | of the communications system, a calling party could be either the end | |||
party could be either the end user device (e.g., a SIP user agent | user device (e.g., a SIP user agent (UA)) or a network service as | |||
(UA)) or a network service as part of a telephone service provider. | part of a telephone service provider. Similarly, a called party | |||
Similarly, a called party could be an end user device or the network | could be an end user device or the network telephone service provider | |||
telephone service provider acting on behalf of the recipient of the | acting on behalf of the recipient of the call. | |||
call. | ||||
In order to properly protect and communicate some of the | In order to properly protect and communicate some of the | |||
authenticated and trusted properties of "rcd" claims defined in | authenticated and trusted properties of "rcd" claims defined in | |||
[RFC9795], this document defines two additional new parameters, | [RFC9795], this document defines two additional new parameters, | |||
'verified' and 'integrity'. These parameters help protect RCD | 'verified' and 'integrity'. These parameters help protect RCD | |||
information that had been sent via a SIP network to, for example, a | information that had been sent via a SIP network to, for example, a | |||
SIP entity on the edge of the Network-Network Interface (NNI) that | SIP entity on the edge of the Network-Network Interface (NNI) that | |||
contains a verification service as defined in [RFC8224] and further | contains a verification service as defined in [RFC8224] and further | |||
defined specific to RCD information in [RFC9795]. The verification | defined specific to RCD information in [RFC9795]. The verification | |||
procedures include the successful verification of the "rcd" claims | procedures include the successful verification of the "rcd" claims | |||
skipping to change at line 172 ¶ | skipping to change at line 172 ¶ | |||
authenticated, network-to-device, trusted signaling where a device | authenticated, network-to-device, trusted signaling where a device | |||
may not have the ability to verify the "rcd" PASSporT, but it can | may not have the ability to verify the "rcd" PASSporT, but it can | |||
receive the RCD information from the Call-Info header field as | receive the RCD information from the Call-Info header field as | |||
defined in this specification. | defined in this specification. | |||
This specification provides an approach for the delivery of jCard | This specification provides an approach for the delivery of jCard | |||
data that utilizes the same mechanism as [RFC7852] which defined a | data that utilizes the same mechanism as [RFC7852] which defined a | |||
means of carrying additional data about callers for the purposes of | means of carrying additional data about callers for the purposes of | |||
emergency services (especially Section 4.4 (Owner/Subscriber | emergency services (especially Section 4.4 (Owner/Subscriber | |||
Information) of [RFC7852]). This document defines a 'purpose' | Information) of [RFC7852]). This document defines a 'purpose' | |||
parameter value 'jcard' for the more generic delivery of information | parameter value "jcard" for the more generic delivery of information | |||
via jCard [RFC7095]. This document borrows from [RFC7852] the | via jCard [RFC7095]. This document borrows from [RFC7852] the | |||
capability to carry a data structure as a body, through the use of | capability to carry a data structure as a body, through the use of | |||
the "cid" URI scheme [RFC2392]. | the "cid" URI scheme [RFC2392]. | |||
2. Terminology | 2. Terminology | |||
The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", | The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", | |||
"SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and | "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and | |||
"OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in | "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in | |||
BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all | BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all | |||
skipping to change at line 241 ¶ | skipping to change at line 241 ¶ | |||
information and identities over untrusted networks, which wasn't | information and identities over untrusted networks, which wasn't | |||
addressed in the core SIP specifications. [RFC3261], Section 20.9 | addressed in the core SIP specifications. [RFC3261], Section 20.9 | |||
defines the Call-Info header field as the mechanism for carrying | defines the Call-Info header field as the mechanism for carrying | |||
call- and caller-related information and also provides procedures for | call- and caller-related information and also provides procedures for | |||
defining new 'purpose' parameter tokens. This document discusses the | defining new 'purpose' parameter tokens. This document discusses the | |||
use of existing tokens and defines a new 'purpose' token to | use of existing tokens and defines a new 'purpose' token to | |||
correspond to the RCD framework. | correspond to the RCD framework. | |||
There are a number of RCD information types that can be transmitted | There are a number of RCD information types that can be transmitted | |||
in the Call-Info header field of a SIP request. The STIR RCD | in the Call-Info header field of a SIP request. The STIR RCD | |||
specification [RFC9795] defines calling name, a logo or icon | specification [RFC9795] defines the following primary RCD elements: a | |||
associated with the caller, and a call reason string. It also | calling name, a logo or icon associated with the caller, and a call | |||
discusses an extensible way to carry caller information using jCard | reason string. It also discusses an extensible way to carry caller | |||
[RFC7095]. | information using jCard [RFC7095]. | |||
The RCD framework defined both in this document as well as in | The RCD framework defined both in this document as well as in | |||
[RFC9795] carries call-specific information. The insertion of RCD is | [RFC9795] carries call-specific information. The insertion of RCD is | |||
intended to be singular in that the receiving party should not be | intended to be singular in that the receiving party should not be | |||
required to make any call-specific decisions based on redundant, | required to make any call-specific decisions based on redundant, | |||
duplicate, or conflicting RCD. The RCD information is either | duplicate, or conflicting RCD. The RCD information is either | |||
intended to be added by a party that is authoritative over that | intended to be added by a party that is authoritative over that | |||
information or to have been translated from a verified STIR RCD | information or to have been translated from a verified STIR RCD | |||
PASSporT and unmodified once in a trusted domain. Any additional | PASSporT and unmodified once in a trusted domain. Any additional | |||
parties involved in the call path MUST NOT modify the Call-Info | parties involved in the call path MUST NOT modify the Call-Info | |||
skipping to change at line 278 ¶ | skipping to change at line 278 ¶ | |||
Asserted-ID header field [RFC3325]. While this is out of scope for | Asserted-ID header field [RFC3325]. While this is out of scope for | |||
the Call-Info header field in terms of the representation of the | the Call-Info header field in terms of the representation of the | |||
display-name value, this document does discuss the representation of | display-name value, this document does discuss the representation of | |||
the verification of this value using the 'verified' parameter. | the verification of this value using the 'verified' parameter. | |||
For logos or icons that can represent the calling party, the | For logos or icons that can represent the calling party, the | |||
'purpose' token "icon" [RFC3261] is used to indicate a URI for an | 'purpose' token "icon" [RFC3261] is used to indicate a URI for an | |||
image resource that can be displayed to the user receiving the SIP | image resource that can be displayed to the user receiving the SIP | |||
request. For the purpose of this document and the transmission of | request. For the purpose of this document and the transmission of | |||
RCD, the "icon" 'purpose' token should be used as defined. | RCD, the "icon" 'purpose' token should be used as defined. | |||
Section 8.2 provides high-level guidance on image formatting and | Section 8.2 of [RFC9795] provides high-level guidance on image | |||
related information. | formatting and related information. | |||
This document defines 'call-reason' as a new parameter for the Call- | This document defines 'call-reason' as a new parameter for the Call- | |||
Info header field. This parameter carries a string indicating the | Info header field. This parameter carries a string indicating the | |||
reason for the call. | reason for the call. | |||
jCard is a comprehensive and extensible mechanism utilized as part of | jCard is a comprehensive and extensible mechanism utilized as part of | |||
the STIR RCD framework. While [RFC3261] specifies a "card" 'purpose' | the STIR RCD framework. While [RFC3261] specifies a "card" 'purpose' | |||
token, the intent of defining a new "jcard" 'purpose' token is to use | token, the intent of defining a new "jcard" 'purpose' token is to use | |||
the JSON jCard format [RFC7095] and to provide guidance for the use | the JSON jCard format [RFC7095] and to provide guidance for the use | |||
and non-use of jCard attributes to describe the calling party in a | and non-use of jCard attributes to describe the calling party in a | |||
skipping to change at line 316 ¶ | skipping to change at line 316 ¶ | |||
carried in the body of the SIP request bearing this Call-Info header | carried in the body of the SIP request bearing this Call-Info header | |||
field via the "cid" URI scheme [RFC2392]. Alternatively, the Call- | field via the "cid" URI scheme [RFC2392]. Alternatively, the Call- | |||
Info header field URI MUST use a transport that can validate the | Info header field URI MUST use a transport that can validate the | |||
integrity of the source of the resource (e.g., HTTPS tied to a | integrity of the source of the resource (e.g., HTTPS tied to a | |||
specific validated domain). If, in the specific deployment | specific validated domain). If, in the specific deployment | |||
environment of SIP, the source or integrity of the RCD information | environment of SIP, the source or integrity of the RCD information | |||
cannot be trusted, then the use of the STIR RCD framework defined in | cannot be trusted, then the use of the STIR RCD framework defined in | |||
[RFC9795] should be considered. | [RFC9795] should be considered. | |||
Because the use and purpose of this specification is to provide a | Because the use and purpose of this specification is to provide a | |||
single presentation of rich call data information, a call and its | single presentation of RCD information, a call and its corresponding | |||
corresponding single RCD-related Call-Info header field MUST only | single RCD-related Call-Info header field MUST only contain a single | |||
contain a single jCard object represented by an array with two | jCard object represented by an array with two elements. The array | |||
elements. The array MUST only include a single first element with | MUST only include a single first element with the string "vcard", and | |||
the string "vcard", and the second element is an array of jCard | the second element is an array of jCard properties corresponding to | |||
properties corresponding to the single entity jCard object. | the single entity jCard object. | |||
The fields like "fn", "photo", or "logo" if used with the use of | jCard has multiple fields that may convey similar information, for | |||
"icon" or calling name in From or P-Asserted-ID header field or | example, "fn", “n”, or “nickname” are strings that represent names in | |||
purpose token, as described in the previous section, MUST match if | different ways, or "photo" or "logo" represent a picture. Users of | |||
present to allow the called party to clearly determine the intended | this specification should make sure there is consistency for the | |||
calling name or icon. | calling name string corresponding to the single name in the SIP From | |||
or P-Asserted-ID header field or a “logo” or “photo” corresponds to | ||||
the RCD “icon” as described in the previous section. As described in | ||||
[RFC8224] and [RFC9795] verification procedures, the values | ||||
represented in the RCD MUST match the corresponding information in | ||||
the SIP message to enable proper verification of calling name or icon | ||||
consistently. | ||||
An example of a Call-Info header field is: | An example of a Call-Info header field is: | |||
Call-Info: <https://example.com/qbranch.json>;purpose=jcard | Call-Info: <https://example.com/qbranch.json>;purpose=jcard | |||
An example of the contents of a URL-linked jCard JSON file is shown | An example of the contents of a URL-linked jCard JSON file is shown | |||
as follows: | as follows: | |||
["vcard", | ["vcard", | |||
[ | [ | |||
skipping to change at line 446 ¶ | skipping to change at line 452 ¶ | |||
SIP implementations and its specification describes its potential use | SIP implementations and its specification describes its potential use | |||
in filtering, it seemed prudent to define a new means of carrying a | in filtering, it seemed prudent to define a new means of carrying a | |||
call-reason indication. | call-reason indication. | |||
An example of a Call-Info header field value with the "call-reason" | An example of a Call-Info header field value with the "call-reason" | |||
parameter follows: | parameter follows: | |||
Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.json>;purpose=jcard; | Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.json>;purpose=jcard; | |||
call-reason="For your ears only" | call-reason="For your ears only" | |||
In the case that there is only a 'call-reason' or 'verified' | For ‘call-reason’ or ‘verified’ parameters defined in this document | |||
parameter or any future parameters that may be defined and no need | that do not require an associated URI, or for future parameters do | |||
for a purpose parameter with no associated URI the null data URI, | not require an associated URI, the Call-Info header field URI should | |||
"data:" is used as the URI. The purpose parameter "jcard", defined | be set to the null data URI, “data:”. The purpose parameter "jcard", | |||
in this document, is used to avoid any conflicts or confusion with | defined in this document, is used to avoid any conflicts or confusion | |||
existing implementations and previously defined purpose parameters. | with existing implementations and previously defined purpose | |||
As an example: | parameters. As an example: | |||
Call-Info: <data:>;purpose=jcard; | Call-Info: <data:>;purpose=jcard; | |||
call-reason="For your ears only" | call-reason="For your ears only" | |||
7. 'verified' Call-Info Parameter | 7. 'verified' Call-Info Parameter | |||
The 'verified' parameter extends and complements the content conveyed | The 'verified' parameter extends and complements the content conveyed | |||
by the RCD-related Call-Info header field. This parameter indicates | by the RCD-related Call-Info header field. This parameter indicates | |||
to the recipient that the information contained in the Call-Info | to the recipient that the information contained in the Call-Info | |||
header field has been verified by verification procedures for claims | header field has been verified by verification procedures for claims | |||
skipping to change at line 478 ¶ | skipping to change at line 484 ¶ | |||
recipient should assume that information was not received and | recipient should assume that information was not received and | |||
verified corresponding to the verification procedures defined in | verified corresponding to the verification procedures defined in | |||
Section 8 of [RFC9795]. | Section 8 of [RFC9795]. | |||
There is a single valid value associated with the 'verified' | There is a single valid value associated with the 'verified' | |||
parameter of 'true'. The value 'true' indicates to the recipient | parameter of 'true'. The value 'true' indicates to the recipient | |||
that the party that included the Call-Info header field performed a | that the party that included the Call-Info header field performed a | |||
successful verification of the information represented. As a general | successful verification of the information represented. As a general | |||
principle of Call-Info header field information, the recipients' | principle of Call-Info header field information, the recipients' | |||
ability to trust the 'verified' parameter is based on the trusted | ability to trust the 'verified' parameter is based on the trusted | |||
relationship of whom they are receiving the SIP request. | relationship with the party from whom they are receiving the SIP | |||
request. | ||||
The following is an example where the parameter verified="true" is | The following is an example where the parameter verified="true" is | |||
used to represent that a verification procedure has been performed | used to represent that a verification procedure has been performed | |||
within a trusted domain to indicate the 'icon' URL has been | within a trusted domain to indicate the "icon" URL has been | |||
successfully verified: | successfully verified: | |||
Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.png>;purpose=icon; | Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.png>;purpose=icon; | |||
verified="true" | verified="true" | |||
In addition to the use of the indication of successful verification | In addition to the use of the indication of successful verification | |||
of RCD information, an important usage of the 'verified' parameter is | of RCD information, an important usage of the 'verified' parameter is | |||
to indicate verification of display-name information, sometimes | to indicate verification of display-name information, sometimes | |||
referred to as calling name or CNAM. | referred to as calling name or CNAM. | |||
skipping to change at line 519 ¶ | skipping to change at line 526 ¶ | |||
} | } | |||
The terminating provider receives a SIP INVITE with an identity | The terminating provider receives a SIP INVITE with an identity | |||
header containing the STIR RCD PASSporT that is verified through a | header containing the STIR RCD PASSporT that is verified through a | |||
verification service. The provider then wants to deliver the call to | verification service. The provider then wants to deliver the call to | |||
an end device in the trusted and authenticated UNI network. The | an end device in the trusted and authenticated UNI network. The | |||
provider uses local policies to determine the information to present | provider uses local policies to determine the information to present | |||
to the end device. The following example SIP INVITE could be used to | to the end device. The following example SIP INVITE could be used to | |||
represent the RCD information using two Call-Info header fields. | represent the RCD information using two Call-Info header fields. | |||
Because both the icon and calling name have passed verification, a | Because both the icon and calling name have passed verification, a | |||
Call-Info header for the 'icon' is added with a verified="true" | Call-Info header for the "icon" is added with a verified="true" | |||
parameter, and the use of Call-Info with a null data URI is used, as | parameter, and the use of Call-Info with a null data URI is used, as | |||
discussed in the "call-reason" section above. This document defines | discussed in the "call-reason" section above. This document defines | |||
the convention that when a Call-Info header field with a null data | that the display-name information in either the From and/or P- | |||
URI, "data:", a default purpose of "jcard" and adding a | Asserted-ID header field has been verified via RCD PASSporT | |||
verified="true" indicates that the display-name information in either | verification procedures when the following is present: a ‘purpose’ | |||
the From and/or P-Asserted-ID header field has been verified via RCD | parameter tokens of “jcard”, a Call-Info header field with a null | |||
verification procedures. | data URI “data:”, and a verified parameter equal to “true”. | |||
Example SIP INVITE described above: | Example SIP INVITE described above: | |||
INVITE sip:qbranch@example.com SIP/2.0 | INVITE sip:qbranch@example.com SIP/2.0 | |||
Via: SIP/2.0/TLS pc33.atlanta.example.com;branch=z9hG4bKnashds8 | Via: SIP/2.0/TLS pc33.atlanta.example.com;branch=z9hG4bKnashds8 | |||
To: "QBranch" <sip:qbranch@example.com> | To: "QBranch" <sip:qbranch@example.com> | |||
From: "James Bond" <sip:12155551000@example.com;user=phone>; | From: "James Bond" <sip:12155551000@example.com;user=phone>; | |||
tag=1928> | tag=1928> | |||
Call-ID: a84b4c76e66710 | Call-ID: a84b4c76e66710 | |||
Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.png>;purpose=icon; | Call-Info: <https://example.com/jbond.png>;purpose=icon; | |||
skipping to change at line 571 ¶ | skipping to change at line 578 ¶ | |||
describes the procedures for the creation of the digest value | describes the procedures for the creation of the digest value | |||
including the hash algorithm indicator a '-' separator and the hash | including the hash algorithm indicator a '-' separator and the hash | |||
value as a string. The JSON pointer object container described as | value as a string. The JSON pointer object container described as | |||
the container of the 'rcdi' hashes is not necessary because each hash | the container of the 'rcdi' hashes is not necessary because each hash | |||
value should only correspond to a single URI. Corresponding to | value should only correspond to a single URI. Corresponding to | |||
guidance defined in Section 6 of [RFC9795], implementations of this | guidance defined in Section 6 of [RFC9795], implementations of this | |||
specification MUST support the hash algorithms SHA-256, SHA-384, and | specification MUST support the hash algorithms SHA-256, SHA-384, and | |||
SHA-512. These hash algorithms are identified by "sha256", "sha384", | SHA-512. These hash algorithms are identified by "sha256", "sha384", | |||
and "sha512", respectively. | and "sha512", respectively. | |||
Typically, this hash value, assuming the URI and the resource pointed | Assuming the URI and the resource pointing to the URI don't change | |||
to the URI don't change between the STIR RCD PASSporT and the Call- | between the STIR RCD PASSporT and the Call- Info URI value, the | |||
Info URI value, the integrity value can be directly used as the same | integrity value can typically be used as the same corresponding | |||
corresponding string in both the "rcdi" claim and the 'integrity' | string in both the "rcdi" claim and the 'integrity' parameter. | |||
parameter string value. | ||||
Note: The inclusion of both the 'verified' and 'integrity' when an | | Note: When the ‘rcdi’ claim is part of the successfully | |||
"rcdi" claim is included and the identity header field and included | | verified RCD PASSporT, the Call-Info Header Field should | |||
PASSporT is verified successfully is the suggested outcome. Creation | | include both the ‘verified’ and ‘integrity’ parameters. | |||
of a Call-Info header field based on an identity header field that | | Creation of a Call-Info header field based on an identity | |||
carries Rich Call Data claims that does not pass verification | | header field that carries RCD claims that does not pass | |||
procedures is not suggested (i.e., the inclusion of an 'integrity' | | verification procedures is not suggested (i.e., the inclusion | |||
parameter without a properly included 'verified' parameter) | | of an 'integrity' parameter without a properly included | |||
| 'verified' parameter). | ||||
Example STIR RCD PASSporT: | Example STIR RCD PASSporT: | |||
Protected Header | Protected Header | |||
{ | { | |||
"alg":"ES256", | "alg":"ES256", | |||
"typ":"passport", | "typ":"passport", | |||
"ppt":"rcd", | "ppt":"rcd", | |||
"x5u":"https://cert.example.org/passport.pem" | "x5u":"https://cert.example.org/passport.pem" | |||
} | } | |||
skipping to change at line 642 ¶ | skipping to change at line 649 ¶ | |||
s=Session SDP | s=Session SDP | |||
c=IN IP4 pc33.atlanta.example.com | c=IN IP4 pc33.atlanta.example.com | |||
t=0 0 | t=0 0 | |||
m=audio 49172 RTP/AVP 0 | m=audio 49172 RTP/AVP 0 | |||
a=rtpmap:0 PCMU/8000 | a=rtpmap:0 PCMU/8000 | |||
9. Usage and an Example of Call-Info for RCD | 9. Usage and an Example of Call-Info for RCD | |||
The procedures for the usage of URIs and 'purpose' parameter tokens | The procedures for the usage of URIs and 'purpose' parameter tokens | |||
should follow the procedures defined in [RFC3261]. The general | should follow the procedures defined in [RFC3261]. The general | |||
management and provisioning of Rich Call Data for an initiating party | management and provisioning of RCD for an initiating party requires a | |||
requires a lot of validation of information regarding that specific | lot of validation of information regarding that specific initiating | |||
initiating party, which is out of scope of this document. Because | party, which is out of scope of this document. Since the ‘rcd’ Call- | |||
the 'rcd' Call-Info header field is inserted as part of the receiving | Info header field is verified during the transition from the Network- | |||
part of the transition from NNI to UNI, the information populated in | to-Network Interface (NNI) to the User-to-Network Interface (UNI), a | |||
a received STIR 'rcd' PASSporT that is verified is a general | common approach is to extract and translate the verified information | |||
anticipated process for translating information into the 'rcd' Call- | from a received STIR ‘rcd’ PASSporT into this header field. This | |||
Info header field to transport the rich call data into the UNI toward | allows the RCD to be delivered to the end user device through the | |||
the end-user device. | UNI. | |||
The following example provides both the STIR RCD PASSporT and the | The following example provides both the STIR RCD PASSporT and the | |||
corresponding set of Call-Info header fields showing the use of | corresponding set of Call-Info header fields showing the use of | |||
multiple 'purpose' parameters to indicate a jCard and an icon and | multiple Call-Info 'purpose' tokens to indicate "jCard" and "icon" | |||
also a 'call-reason' parameter: | and also a 'call-reason' Call-Info parameter: | |||
Example STIR RCD PASSporT: | Example STIR RCD PASSporT: | |||
Protected Header | Protected Header | |||
{ | { | |||
"alg":"ES256", | "alg":"ES256", | |||
"typ":"passport", | "typ":"passport", | |||
"ppt":"rcd", | "ppt":"rcd", | |||
"x5u":"https://cert.example.org/passport.pem" | "x5u":"https://cert.example.org/passport.pem" | |||
} | } | |||
skipping to change at line 712 ¶ | skipping to change at line 719 ¶ | |||
as well as applications, and also includes requirements specific to | as well as applications, and also includes requirements specific to | |||
textual and graphics-capable displays. | textual and graphics-capable displays. | |||
10.1. Usage of URIs in jCard | 10.1. Usage of URIs in jCard | |||
When one or more URIs are used in a jCard, it is important to note | When one or more URIs are used in a jCard, it is important to note | |||
that any URI-referenced data, with the exception of the top-level | that any URI-referenced data, with the exception of the top-level | |||
usage of "jcl" as a URI to the jCard itself MUST NOT contain any URI | usage of "jcl" as a URI to the jCard itself MUST NOT contain any URI | |||
references. In other words, the jCard can have URI references as | references. In other words, the jCard can have URI references as | |||
defined in the jCard specification and this document, but the content | defined in the jCard specification and this document, but the content | |||
referenced by those URIs MUST NOT have any URIs, and therefore MUST | referenced by those URIs MUST NOT have any URIs; therefore, the | |||
be enforced by the client to not follow those URI references or not | client MUST ensure that those URI references are not followed, and | |||
render that content to the user if any URI are present in that | any URIs that are present in that specific URI-linked content are not | |||
specific URI linked content. The purpose of this is to control the | rendered. The purpose of this is to control the security and more | |||
security and more specifically to align with the content-integrity | specifically to align with the content-integrity mechanism defined in | |||
mechanism defined in [RFC9795]. There is not anticipated to be need | [RFC9795]. There is not anticipated to be need for which deeper URI | |||
for which deeper URI references would be required or even supported | references would be required or even supported by the typical use of | |||
by the typical use of current jCard properties. However, because | current jCard properties. However, because jCard is extensible, this | |||
jCard is extensible, this rule is set to restrict further extension | rule is set to restrict further extension without the proper | |||
without the proper consideration of security and integrity properties | consideration of security and integrity properties of both Call-Info | |||
of both Call-Info usage as well as the RCD and STIR signing of the | usage as well as the RCD and STIR signing of the data [RFC9795] | |||
data [RFC9795] [RFC8224]. | [RFC8224]. | |||
10.2. Usage of Multimedia Data in jCard or with Icon | 10.2. Usage of Multimedia Data in jCard or with the “icon” Call-Info | |||
‘purpose’ Token | ||||
For the use of the 'purpose' token "icon" or for the cases where the | For the use of the 'purpose' token "icon" or for the cases where the | |||
jCard either incorporates URIs or includes digital images and sounds | jCard either incorporates URIs or includes digital images and sounds | |||
directly via Base64 encoding (Section 4 of [RFC4648]), this document | directly via Base64 encoding (Section 4 of [RFC4648]), this document | |||
provides guidance at the time of writing that can be adopted to | provides guidance at the time of writing that can be adopted to | |||
facilitate the successful decoding and rendering of these images and | facilitate the successful decoding and rendering of these images and | |||
media formats. Note that media formats are likely something | media formats. Note that media formats are likely something | |||
implementers need to consider for their specific application. | implementers need to consider for their specific application. | |||
For images, such as for the "photo" and "logo" properties, the | For images, such as for the "photo" and "logo" properties, the | |||
skipping to change at line 924 ¶ | skipping to change at line 932 ¶ | |||
10.6.1. "tel" Property | 10.6.1. "tel" Property | |||
The "tel" property provides the telephone number for the object the | The "tel" property provides the telephone number for the object the | |||
jCard represents. Reference: [RFC6350], Section 6.4.1. | jCard represents. Reference: [RFC6350], Section 6.4.1. | |||
Relative to the SIP From header field value, this information may | Relative to the SIP From header field value, this information may | |||
provide an alternate telephone number or other related telephone | provide an alternate telephone number or other related telephone | |||
numbers for other uses. | numbers for other uses. | |||
It is important to note that any of the potential instances of the | It is important to note that any of the instances of the "tel" | |||
"tel" property should not be considered part of the authentication or | property should not be considered part of the authentication or | |||
verification part of STIR [RFC8224] or required to match the "orig" | verification part of STIR [RFC8224] or required to match the "orig" | |||
claim in the PASSporT [RFC8225]. These telephone numbers can be for | claim in the PASSporT [RFC8225]. These telephone numbers can be for | |||
contact, fax, or other purposes aligned with the general usage of | contact, fax, or other purposes aligned with the general usage of | |||
jCard and vCard, but the potential confusion of the callee when | jCard and vCard, but the potential confusion of the callee when | |||
provided with multiple telephone numbers instead of the actual, | provided with multiple telephone numbers instead of the actual, | |||
verified telephone number should be considered from a general policy | verified telephone number should be considered from a general policy | |||
point of view. | point of view. | |||
Value type: By default, it is a single free-form text value (for | Value type: By default, it is a single free-form text value (for | |||
backward compatibility with vCard 3), but it SHOULD be reset to a | backward compatibility with vCard 3), but it SHOULD be reset to a | |||
skipping to change at line 981 ¶ | skipping to change at line 989 ¶ | |||
10.7. Geographical Properties | 10.7. Geographical Properties | |||
These properties provide geographical information associated with the | These properties provide geographical information associated with the | |||
object the jCard represents. | object the jCard represents. | |||
10.7.1. "tz" Property | 10.7.1. "tz" Property | |||
The "tz" property provides the time zone of the object the jCard | The "tz" property provides the time zone of the object the jCard | |||
represents. Reference: [RFC6350], Section 6.5.1. | represents. Reference: [RFC6350], Section 6.5.1. | |||
Note: The reference for time-zone names is <https://www.iana.org/ | | Note: The reference for time-zone names is | |||
time-zones>. | | <https://www.iana.org/time-zones>. | |||
Value type: The default is a single text value. It can also be | Value type: The default is a single text value. It can also be | |||
reset to a single URI or a UTC-offset value. | reset to a single URI or a UTC-offset value. | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["tz", {}, "text", "America/New_York"] | ["tz", {}, "text", "America/New_York"] | |||
10.7.2. "geo" Property | 10.7.2. "geo" Property | |||
skipping to change at line 1010 ¶ | skipping to change at line 1018 ¶ | |||
["geo", {}, "uri", "geo:37.386013,-122.082932"] | ["geo", {}, "uri", "geo:37.386013,-122.082932"] | |||
10.8. Organizational Properties | 10.8. Organizational Properties | |||
These properties are concerned with information associated with | These properties are concerned with information associated with | |||
characteristics of the organization or organizational units of the | characteristics of the organization or organizational units of the | |||
object that the jCard represents. | object that the jCard represents. | |||
10.8.1. "title" Property | 10.8.1. "title" Property | |||
The "title" property has the intent of providing the position or job | The "title" property provides the position or job of the object the | |||
of the object the jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], | jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], Section 6.6.1. | |||
Section 6.6.1. | ||||
Value type: A single text value. | Value type: A single text value. | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["title", {}, "text", "Research Scientist"] | ["title", {}, "text", "Research Scientist"] | |||
10.8.2. "role" Property | 10.8.2. "role" Property | |||
The "role" property has the intent of providing the position or job | The "role" property provides the position or job of the object the | |||
of the object the jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], | jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], Section 6.6.2. | |||
Section 6.6.2. | ||||
Value type: A single text value. | Value type: A single text value. | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["role", {}, "text", "Project Leader"] | ["role", {}, "text", "Project Leader"] | |||
10.8.3. "logo" Property | 10.8.3. "logo" Property | |||
The "logo" property has the intent of specifying a graphic image of a | The "logo" property specifies a graphic image of a logo associated | |||
logo associated with the object the jCard represents. Reference | with the object the jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], | |||
[RFC6350], Section 6.6.3. | Section 6.6.3. | |||
Value type: A single URI. | Value type: A single URI. | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["logo", {}, "uri", "http://www.example.com/abccorp-512x512.jpg"] | ["logo", {}, "uri", "http://www.example.com/abccorp-512x512.jpg"] | |||
["logo", {}, "uri", " | ["logo", {}, "uri", " | |||
AQEEBQAwdzELMAkGA1UEBhMCVVMxLDAqBgNVBAoTI05ldHNjYXBlIENvbW11bm | AQEEBQAwdzELMAkGA1UEBhMCVVMxLDAqBgNVBAoTI05ldHNjYXBlIENvbW11bm | |||
ljYXRpb25zIENvcnBvcmF0aW9uMRwwGgYDVQQLExNJbmZvcm1hdGlvbiBTeXN0 | ljYXRpb25zIENvcnBvcmF0aW9uMRwwGgYDVQQLExNJbmZvcm1hdGlvbiBTeXN0 | |||
<...the remainder of base64-encoded data...>"] | <...the remainder of base64-encoded data...>"] | |||
10.8.4. "org" Property | 10.8.4. "org" Property | |||
The "org" property has the intent of specifying the organizational | The "org" property specifies the organizational name and units of the | |||
name and units of the object the jCard represents. Reference | object the jCard represents. Reference [RFC6350], Section 6.6.4. | |||
[RFC6350], Section 6.6.4. | ||||
Value type: A single structured text value consisting of components | Value type: A single structured text value consisting of components | |||
separated by the SEMICOLON character (U+003B). | separated by the SEMICOLON character (U+003B). | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["org", {}, "text", "ABC\, Inc.;North American Division;Marketing"] | ["org", {}, "text", "ABC\, Inc.;North American Division;Marketing"] | |||
10.9. Explanatory Properties | 10.9. Explanatory Properties | |||
skipping to change at line 1135 ¶ | skipping to change at line 1140 ¶ | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["uid", {}, "uri", "urn:uuid:f81d4fae-7dec-11d0-a765-00a0c91e6bf6"] | ["uid", {}, "uri", "urn:uuid:f81d4fae-7dec-11d0-a765-00a0c91e6bf6"] | |||
10.9.5. "url" Property | 10.9.5. "url" Property | |||
The "url" property specifies a uniform resource locator associated | The "url" property specifies a uniform resource locator associated | |||
with the object the jCard represents. Reference: [RFC6350], | with the object the jCard represents. Reference: [RFC6350], | |||
Section 6.7.8. | Section 6.7.8. | |||
There are potential security and privacy implications of providing | There are potential security and privacy implications of providing | |||
URLs with telephone calls. The end client receiving a jCard with a | URLs with telephone calls. | |||
"url" property MUST only display the URL and not automatically follow | ||||
the URL or provide an automatic preview of the URL, and generally | The end client receiving a jCard with a "url" property MUST only | |||
provide good practices in making it clear to the user it is their | display the URL and not automatically follow the URL or provide an | |||
choice to follow the URL in a browser context consistent with all of | automatic preview of the URL. In addition, it MUST generally adhere | |||
to good practice to make it clear to the user that it is their choice | ||||
whether to follow the URL in a browser context consistent with all of | ||||
the common browser security and privacy practices available on most | the common browser security and privacy practices available on most | |||
consumer OS environments. | consumer OS environments. | |||
Value type: A single uri value. | Value type: A single uri value. | |||
Cardinality: * | Cardinality: * | |||
Example: | Example: | |||
["url", {}, "uri", "https://example.org/french-rest/chezchic.html"] | ["url", {}, "uri", "https://example.org/french-rest/chezchic.html"] | |||
10.9.6. "version" Property | 10.9.6. "version" Property | |||
skipping to change at line 1172 ¶ | skipping to change at line 1179 ¶ | |||
Part of the intent of using jCard is to leverage its extensibility to | Part of the intent of using jCard is to leverage its extensibility to | |||
define new properties to relay new information related to a caller. | define new properties to relay new information related to a caller. | |||
This capability is inherently supported as part of standard | This capability is inherently supported as part of standard | |||
extensibility. However, usage of those new properties should be | extensibility. However, usage of those new properties should be | |||
published and registered following [RFC7095], Section 3.6 or as | published and registered following [RFC7095], Section 3.6 or as | |||
defined in future specifications. | defined in future specifications. | |||
12. IANA Considerations | 12. IANA Considerations | |||
12.1. 'jcard' Purpose Parameter Value | 12.1. "jcard" Purpose Parameter Value | |||
This document defines the 'jcard' value for the 'purpose' parameter | This document defines the "jcard" value for the 'purpose' parameter | |||
of the Call-Info header field [RFC3261]. IANA has added this | of the Call-Info header field [RFC3261]. IANA has added this | |||
document to the list of references for the 'purpose' value of Call- | document to the list of references for the 'purpose' value of Call- | |||
Info in the "Header Field Parameters and Parameter Values" registry | Info in the "Header Field Parameters and Parameter Values" registry | |||
within the "Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) Parameters" registry | within the "Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) Parameters" registry | |||
group. | group. | |||
12.2. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'call-reason' Parameter | 12.2. SIP Call-Info Header Field 'call-reason' Parameter | |||
This document defines the 'call-reason' generic parameter for use in | This document defines the 'call-reason' generic parameter for use in | |||
the Call-Info header field in the "Header Field Parameters and | the Call-Info header field in the "Header Field Parameters and | |||
skipping to change at line 1238 ¶ | skipping to change at line 1245 ¶ | |||
13. Security Considerations | 13. Security Considerations | |||
Revealing information such as the name, location, and affiliation of | Revealing information such as the name, location, and affiliation of | |||
a person necessarily entails certain privacy risks. The SIP Call- | a person necessarily entails certain privacy risks. The SIP Call- | |||
Info header field has no particular confidentiality requirement, as | Info header field has no particular confidentiality requirement, as | |||
the information sent in SIP is in the clear anyway. Transport-level | the information sent in SIP is in the clear anyway. Transport-level | |||
security can be used to hide information from eavesdroppers, and the | security can be used to hide information from eavesdroppers, and the | |||
same confidentiality mechanisms would protect any Call-Info or jCard | same confidentiality mechanisms would protect any Call-Info or jCard | |||
information carried or referred to in SIP. | information carried or referred to in SIP. | |||
The use of the Call-Info header for transporting Rich Call Data | The use of the Call-Info header for transporting RCD ('rcd') is | |||
('rcd') is intended primarily for providing verified information at | intended primarily for providing verified information at the | |||
the termination of a call, where a verification service has a trusted | termination of a call, where a verification service has a trusted UNI | |||
UNI relationship with the user agent. To ensure the integrity and | relationship with the user agent. To ensure the integrity and | |||
authenticity of this data, the security framework established by | authenticity of this data, the security framework established by | |||
STIR, including the use of the 'rcd'PASSporT as defined in [RFC9795], | STIR, including the use of the 'rcd'PASSporT as defined in [RFC9795], | |||
should be followed. This framework enables digital signatures to | should be followed. This framework enables digital signatures to | |||
verify the issuer of assertions related to the calling party's | verify the issuer of assertions related to the calling party's | |||
identity, distinguishing persistent identity attributes from | identity, distinguishing persistent identity attributes from | |||
transient, per-call details. Implementers should also consider | transient, per-call details. Implementers should also consider | |||
certificate-based constraints to ensure proper binding between caller | certificate-based constraints to ensure proper binding between caller | |||
identity assertions and call-specific metadata while maintaining the | identity assertions and call-specific metadata while maintaining the | |||
integrity of the information throughout transmission. Since Call- | integrity of the information throughout transmission. Since Call- | |||
Info serves as a means to convey verified caller information to the | Info serves as a means to convey verified caller information to the | |||
end user, mechanisms should be in place to validate the authenticity | end user, mechanisms should be in place to validate the authenticity | |||
of the assertion, enforce appropriate certificate associations, and | of the assertion, enforce appropriate certificate associations, and | |||
preserve the trustworthiness of Rich Call Data from origination to | preserve the trustworthiness of RCD from origination to termination. | |||
termination. | ||||
The SIP framework, defined in [RFC3261] and the various extensions to | The SIP framework, defined in [RFC3261] and the various extensions to | |||
SIP which includes STIR [RFC8224] and rich call data [RFC9795], since | SIP which includes STIR [RFC8224] and RCD [RFC9795], has always | |||
its existence has provided mechanisms to assert information about the | provided mechanisms to assert information about the person or entity | |||
person or entity behind the call. This feature that can be a benefit | behind the call. This feature that can be a benefit to the SIP | |||
to the SIP network that allows users to help identify the calling | network that allows users to help identify the calling party behind | |||
party behind an abstract telephone number. It can also enable the | an abstract telephone number. It can also enable the ability for | |||
ability for actors to impersonate a calling party they are not | actors to impersonate a calling party they are not authorized to | |||
authorized to represent. The core security consideration that has | represent. The core security consideration that has either | |||
either explicitly or implicitly been acknowledged with any of the SIP | explicitly or implicitly been acknowledged with any of the SIP and | |||
and STIR specifications is that there be a management and policy | STIR specifications is that there be a management and policy layer | |||
layer that validates the participants in the ecosystem and their use | that validates the participants in the ecosystem and their use of a | |||
of a SIP network with telephone number identifiers and identity- | SIP network with telephone number identifiers and identity-related | |||
related information. The use of this specification should weigh this | information. Users should assess this risk and make the appropriate | |||
responsibility and make the appropriate considerations to validate | adjustments to validate proper participation while following these | |||
the proper participation and use of these tools following these | tools following these larger security, impersonation prevention, and | |||
larger security, impersonation prevention, and privacy | privacy considerations. | |||
considerations. | ||||
The use of this specification with the insertion of metadata related | The use of this specification with the insertion of metadata related | |||
to a caller or the purpose of the call should recognize the risk that | to a caller or the purpose of the call should recognize the risk that | |||
this information can be viewed by those network elements and | this information can be viewed by those network elements and | |||
participants in the delivery of the SIP call. The insertion of media | participants in the delivery of the SIP call. The insertion of media | |||
directly or via Base64 encoding or using a remote URI that query | directly or via Base64 encoding or using a remote URI that query | |||
network resources should be considered as a potential threat vector | network resources should be considered as a potential threat vector | |||
to the user or user agent that could potentially allow the parsing of | to the user or user agent that could potentially allow the parsing of | |||
documents crafted to trigger a bug or install a virus. Remote access | documents crafted to trigger a bug or install a virus. Remote access | |||
to URI content should additionally be considered as potentially | to URI content should additionally be considered as potentially | |||
exposing information about that user or user agent. Some sensitive | exposing information about that user or user agent. Some sensitive | |||
users may desire the ability to control or disable these mechanisms | users may desire the ability to control or disable these mechanisms | |||
entirely, and methods to restrict or disable the potential exposure | entirely, and methods to restrict or disable the potential exposure | |||
should be considered to mitigate these concerns. Largely, any | should be considered to mitigate these concerns. Largely, any | |||
information that is included in rich call data should be considered | information that is included in RCD should be considered public, and | |||
public, and this specification does not define any mechanism to | this specification does not define any mechanism to protect this | |||
protect this information beyond the security and privacy associated | information beyond the security and privacy associated with the SIP | |||
with the SIP signalling itself. This is a property that is | signalling itself. This is a property that is consistent with SIP | |||
consistent with SIP more generally, and this specification follows a | more generally, and this specification follows a similar pattern for | |||
similar pattern for its use. | its use. | |||
This specification contains the ability to include media resources | This specification contains the ability to include media resources | |||
and URI and URL resource references to media resources that could | and URI and URL resource references to media resources that could | |||
pose a threat when referencing or decoding the content of these media | pose a threat when referencing or decoding the content of these media | |||
resources, which is similar to threats that web browsers and other | resources, which is similar to threats that web browsers and other | |||
media decoding applications must be concerned about. A network- | media decoding applications must be concerned about. Network | |||
specific set of policies or best practices for the use and hosting of | administrators should consider a network-specific set of policies or | |||
media content that is agreed to contain validated media resources | best practices for the use and hosting of media content that is | |||
that have been evaluated to not pose a security threat to the | agreed to contain validated media resources that have been evaluated | |||
participants or the devices supported in the ecosystem should be | to not pose a security threat to the participants or the devices | |||
considered. | supported in the ecosystem. | |||
14. References | 14. References | |||
14.1. Normative References | 14.1. Normative References | |||
[ISOPNG] ISO/IEC, "Information technology -- Computer graphics and | [ISOPNG] ISO/IEC, "Information technology -- Computer graphics and | |||
image processing -- Portable Network Graphics (PNG), | image processing -- Portable Network Graphics (PNG), | |||
Functional specification", ISO/IEC 15948:2004, March 2004, | Functional specification", ISO/IEC 15948:2004, March 2004, | |||
<https://www.iso.org/standard/29581.html>. | <https://www.iso.org/standard/29581.html>. | |||
skipping to change at line 1397 ¶ | skipping to change at line 1402 ¶ | |||
Token", RFC 8225, DOI 10.17487/RFC8225, February 2018, | Token", RFC 8225, DOI 10.17487/RFC8225, February 2018, | |||
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8225>. | <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8225>. | |||
[RFC8259] Bray, T., Ed., "The JavaScript Object Notation (JSON) Data | [RFC8259] Bray, T., Ed., "The JavaScript Object Notation (JSON) Data | |||
Interchange Format", STD 90, RFC 8259, | Interchange Format", STD 90, RFC 8259, | |||
DOI 10.17487/RFC8259, December 2017, | DOI 10.17487/RFC8259, December 2017, | |||
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8259>. | <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8259>. | |||
[RFC9795] Wendt, C. and J. Peterson, "Personal Assertion Token | [RFC9795] Wendt, C. and J. Peterson, "Personal Assertion Token | |||
(PASSporT) Extension for Rich Call Data", RFC 9795, | (PASSporT) Extension for Rich Call Data", RFC 9795, | |||
DOI 10.17487/RFC9795, May 2025, | DOI 10.17487/RFC9795, June 2025, | |||
<https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc9795>. | <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc9795>. | |||
[W3C-SRI] Akhawe, D., Ed., Braun, F., Ed., Marier, F., Ed., and J. | [W3C-SRI] Akhawe, D., Ed., Braun, F., Ed., Marier, F., Ed., and J. | |||
Weinberger, Ed., "Subresource Integrity", W3C | Weinberger, Ed., "Subresource Integrity", W3C | |||
Recommendation, 23 June 2016, | Recommendation, 23 June 2016, | |||
<https://www.w3.org/TR/2016/REC-SRI-20160623/>. | <https://www.w3.org/TR/2016/REC-SRI-20160623/>. | |||
[W3C-SVGTiny1.2] | [W3C-SVGTiny1.2] | |||
Anderssone, O., Ed., Berjon, R., Ed., Dahlström, E., Ed., | Anderssone, O., Ed., Berjon, R., Ed., Dahlström, E., Ed., | |||
Emmons, A., Ed., Ferraiolo, J., Ed., Grasso, A., Ed., | Emmons, A., Ed., Ferraiolo, J., Ed., Grasso, A., Ed., | |||
End of changes. 34 change blocks. | ||||
136 lines changed or deleted | 141 lines changed or added | |||
This html diff was produced by rfcdiff 1.48. |